@BPH a few weeks ago you posted a report and I thought, he needs to find a new place or make a few trips to Philly for a while.
When you play in the streets like you have been, things happen. It's part of it. Be happy you haven't caught some STI....or some crazy hasn't called the cops on you.
Anytime you set up shop and become a regular at a venue you develop a reputation because everyone talks. That familiarity always breeds some level of drama eventually as you have discovered.
Give this place a break for a few weeks. Do something else other than women for a while. Every man needs a break from doing this type of thing every weekend. Use the time off to think about your career path figuring out living arrangement that don't involve your parents. You'll find that as you get older it will become more important. Your days of getting by are coming to an end.
And when you go back to this same bar(s), don't make it your goal to seduce every hottie there. Be more selective on who you really want. Avoid the ones that get buyers remorse and talk schitt. Do a better job of screening up front and figuring out what kind of girl they are before you have sex with them.
Just because you can, doesn't mean you should.
I'd go there one night this weekend in observational mode & have a drink & show up. I agree this is par for the course but he also needs to do as he pleases and show that these chicks have not run him off.
Leave earlier than closing hour. If some girl gets snarky, excuse himself & say, gotta run, got plans....wink & cruise.
Meanwhile fish in other fishing holes elsewhere too. Scarcity does add value to an environment as does unpredictability, that is true. But don't vanish entirely.
I've been in environments where the same people matriculate. Really its like that everywhere, from NYC to a small town. The hotspots are the hotspots, and thats where the cool people go.
My husband & I are well known at the places we frequent, and I've always been somewhat high profile in nightlife environments throughout my adult life. It comes with its own set of complications of course, but I'll take it over invisibility or irrelevance any day.
Here is the thing I think is coming off weird about
@BPH.....he said it himself.
"I'm a decent guy who enjoys multiple women"
That is the percieved incongruence right there.
That is why I say double down on the bad boyness. Be, on the surface, less nice. Quit trying too hard, quit placating, quit back pedaling.
Most women think their poo doesn't stink and also think they have the magic naughty bits. Women tend to think they deserve exclusivity and demigoddess status from the moment you say hello to her, and they get all upset when this little fantasy bubble of unreasonable expectation pops. This is complete unreality of course when a girl is dealing with a desirable man.
If some immature girl says "Eeew, you're old. Why are you here?????" you need a succint answer...a shut down answer.
"Would you date an overweight divorced guy with a 2 year old and a 4 year old and a crazy ex? Does that sound fun?"
She'll say some variety of 'No way. Duh.'
You say "Me neither. I'd rather date someone fun & chill who I can build something with rather than inherit some other guy's problems."
Women will think you are douchy if you try to come off "decent" but want to play the field. Drop the decency. Double down on bad boy. If some girl is good enough to commit to at some point? Let her prove that to you over time. Reward her.
This is why I succeed with the player archetype my dear. I KNOW what I bring to the table is well over and above a girl who is getting by on just a pretty face and hot body, although I certainly have those bases covered. I also understand that exclusivity is earned, and that I am not the only woman a desirable man is seeing at first. That's fine. Let the other insecure 'looks only' women blow themselves out. They will. I KNOW that. I just need to be chill and cool, but also with my own set of options....
Those playboys fall and fall hard my dear

.
So drop the 'but I'm a decent guy' trope and embrace who you are & what you want as a man. And do not apologize.