Alright, I got more replies than I was expecting, and I decided to do some reflection. Before I do that, I want to go over some points, rather than quote so many people individually:
- Regarding the Tea app...I've done my research, and the experience of several people in the same position as myself has had no response from any of Tea's support emails. I assume they are inundated with similar requests for takedowns. It is only when Apple legal was involved that a response from Tea was necessary. Because the app is no longer searchable to be included in that form for Apple, I cannot submit that takedown through that channel. I've asked the person who was able to get their request answered via this method what email Apple replied with, so I can contact them directly, and I am waiting for a response. I'll figure it out, either through Apple or Google Play.
- Regarding texting the girl from Exhibit C...my thought was that at the very least, I've denied what I've been accused of. She is likely to show several other girls what's been posted about me - she probably has already. I figure that at least now, she has the other side of that equation, regardless of whether she plans to share that, say she doesn't believe it, whatever. Of course, it doesn't matter; I'm not trying to win her over, just give my side.
- Regarding the conversation with the girl from Exhibit C in the bar last night...I didn't go to her; she came to me - twice. The second time around was while I was just sitting, sipping, in "observational mode", so I let her say what she wanted to say. One of the suggestions was to loudly say "I have nothing to say to you" and continue ignoring and moving away from her. Maybe that would've gone better, maybe not.
- Regarding the girl with the fake phone number...as others have stated - which I also advise - calling it in front of her to verify. I did, but at this point, her other friend was pulling her along, so I didn't get her to stick around long enough to check that. Not a major point, just something else annoying to add to the night.
- Regarding the heavy drinking...there's probably some validity to that. At this bar, I'm close with most of the bartenders, so they hook me up when they serve me. This usually means my drinks are all doubles, and I'm not paying for most of them. I'm a big guy with a high tolerance, but this is probably affecting my judgment, yeah. I'm not blacking out, forgetting parts of the night, puking, or pissing myself, but it is true that I probably wouldn't have a similar issue at another bar. I can certainly moderate. I'd just say sometimes I'm overconfident.
- Regarding the "vibe" of the bar...one thing I DID note in "observation mode" is that nobody is really hooking up with anybody. Girls are letting guys talk to them and buy them drinks. Guys are standing around with friends, just drinking and looking around. There is very little interplay. I saw only one couple making out in a dark corner, and I saw almost no guys leave with a girl. The bar isn't a "chill and relaxed" vibe - it's busy, packed closely together, with loud rap and hip hop music playing. Though, as mentioned before, even by the bartenders, this is the first year where there's regularly been no line to get in. It's also been the first year I've seen them cut sections early. Whether that's because these kids are going to an afterparty or just lack social skills and are headed home early, I'm not sure.
- Regarding going into "observation mode"...yeah, that didn't go well for me. After 40 or so minutes just sitting at the bar, pretending to give a sh** about whatever game was on, and just scanning around, looking at who was there started to feel like a waste of time. I didn't have anybody "poke the bear", so with about an hour before close, I decided to walk around a bit, which led to the night I described.
- Regarding "those who can't do, teach", and that I should "already know"...I'm just having a bad time recently. I still know what I'm doing: @nicksaiz65 just hooked up with his former FWB again after I helped him see what she was really doing when she got mad at him and "no longer wanted to see him" after he hit on another coworker - he was going to cut her off and just next her. I helped my buddy by texting on his behalf, and he almost got laid, if not for the fact that his girl fell asleep because he took too long. And I predicted what was going to happen with @Divorced w 3 and his ex in the no contact thread with a pretty high degree of accuracy. I'm not without mistakes, and don't think being really good at something means that I'd be perfect, but I'm just having a bad time. I've still been successful; that last LR was only 3 weeks ago. I'm just dealing with a lot more BS that's starting to put me in a poor mental state, and making me sloppy.
What I've been reflecting on is the WHAT, WHERE, WHEN, and to a lesser extent, WHY of this problem...
WHAT: I'm dealing with an uncharacteristically high level of BS to have a positive result with these college girls at the nearby bars where I've been historically quite successful.
WHERE: I'm dealing with this BS almost exclusively at this singular college bar. And I'm dealing with this singular college bar because I have the best relationship with the staff, where I skip lines, get served quickly, and get served "extra".
WHEN: This has only been happening over the course of the last 2 months, since school started back up and the bar became busy again. Before that, I wasn't having issues in Philadelphia or Ocean City.
WHY: Due to my age. I'd made posts about this as early as when I was 28, I think, and now that I'm in another decade, it seems worse. Regardless of how I look or act, a lot of girls in this bar think it is weird or creepy that I am not pursuing women my own age, as evidenced by some comments on that Tea app. That app is an additional WHY. That big, ugly post about me has been live for almost a full year. My red flag count is high, and whoever posted me tagged me for Delaware, Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and Maryland. I'm highly visible, and while this is the first time this app has impacted me DIRECTLY, I have no clue who else might've made their decision about me based off that comment.
SOLUTION: This cycle of dealing with bad behavior has put me in a poor headspace, even despite my recent success, and I'm getting sloppy. I feel like I'm trying to force a square peg through a round hole. I only default to this bar because it is the closest to me, often has a decent turnout of good-looking women, and I have great relationships with the staff, which benefits me. The women being younger and the age gap being larger is a byproduct of not having great alternatives to meet attractive women - not by virtue of them just being younger. The simple tradeoff is going to be traveling further, at greater expense and inconvenience, so that I won't be wasting my time and resources on this bad behavior. Others have already suggested this, but I wanted to try making an appearance and showing that I haven't been run off by this girl's comments - as stated before, it would be like an admission of guilt. But if I'm going to fight an uphill battle anytime a girl asks me my age or who I'm there with, it's not worth repeating the cycle I'm in now.