I don't know what is the "New Age" advice - Red Pill? Looksmaxing? Or something else?
I've found PUA community in I think 2000 (or maybe 2001) and I know a lot about it. I've met some well known names like Tyler, Papa, Julien and others in real life.
PUA community was always full of
LIES and
LIARS. Many people there enjoyed posing as some kind of "master seducers", pretending they have some kind of elite skills, that they're getting huge sucess with very hot women... While in reality, they were kind of normal guys who were doing mass approaching and were sometimes (rarely) getting laid with mostly women from the 4-7 range.
The "Old Age" advice was always working much worse than advertised. Lots of people tried their hand at PUA and failed, had very poor results. And of course the "looks don't matter" propaganda was always insane nonsense.
So if somebody finds that old PUA advice doesn't work for him, it's not necessarily because the society has changed - many PUAs in 2000s also had very poor results. (Even though it was indeed easier back then.)
YES!
And that was
INSANE.
1. Yes - coaches themselves couldn't do the supposed "miracles" they were describing (really: which they were lying about). Some of them had good results with women, but they were physically attractive. While others had mediocre results or even sucked hard with women.
2. I'd be careful with Youtube and generally with video infields - coaches can film fake, staged infields with hired women. Famously, Tom Torero got caught for hiring an aspiring, low-level actress for a supposed "infield". But some other coaches are also known for doing that.
Also, some do fake real life seduction presentations. They organise a meeting, "free lecture" for local PUA guys.... Then propose they all go to a club. And they send hired woman or women, silenced by NDA with threat of heavy financial penalties, inside the club. The coach approches the hired girl and supposedly "seduces her" - while the local PUA guys watch it wide-eyed and think the guy is a genuine master seducer. Later the local PUA guys pay for his workshops - because they want to learn from a "true master" - and the money paid for the hired woman or women returns to the coach with big surplus.
EXACTLY! And we don't see it because that doesn't work like that, it doesn't happen.
Hi there!

Check your email (not private messages on forum - email)
You know this already, but I've met Tyler and seen him in action - he sucked HARD, he seemed delusional and retarded. He got strong rejections, in the vibe of "go lost retard!", but acted like he somehow thinks it's great game.
Tyler and Papa are some of the worst, most disguisting people I have ever met.
There is some value in the PUA stuff. Despite all the lies and all the nonsense, people from that community did thousands of approaches - collectively I guess millions of approaches. And there is some insight from practical experience, some real knowledge in the PUA community - unfortunately, it's mixed with lies and marketing. And it certainly doesn't work as well as advertised.
Myself, I have benefited A LOT from finding the PUA community - first of all I learned to approach!!! And my mind had contact with different concepts, ideas about women I wouldn't think of before...
But I also suffered because of PUA community - that is my results with women have suffered when I was trying to implement their methods. I do much better when I'm normally talking with women.
BTW After all the experience I've got, I think Gunwitch is the best "seduction guru" - I didn't like him initially, but after many years I've realised that what I'm seeing in real life matches what he was saying long ago.