I’ve been around for about a year and a half, and the phases I’ve seen include the Mr. Amsterdam Assassin situation and the wave of incels who briefly took over the forum. Basically, trolls and guys who refused to take the advice seriously, constantly asking the same questions or going on women-hating rants, diluted the quality of discussion.
Like I mentioned in another post, I’d like to believe that when members leave, it’s because the advice actually helped them. For example, there was that Plato guy who kept chasing the same girl in his dance class and I think he eventually dropped it. Then there was the Oatmeal guy who kept doing direct approaches while working at a restaurant. He stopped posting, and maybe he finally had some success with a coworker. There was also another guy who pursued a coworker for over a year, eventually had the guts to ask her out, got rejected, but then moved on and disappeared from the forum.
The point is: if the advice works, it’s only natural for people to move on with their lives. The lack of traffic might just mean that the newer guys with issues aren’t posting, are finding other outlets, or never found this place in the first place. Ironically, it might also be that the experienced guys aren’t venting anymore because they’ve figured things out and there is no reason to whine.