Rejected Before She Even Got to Know Me

Noahwilson

Don Juan
Joined
Aug 13, 2026
Messages
21
Reaction score
10
Age
26
Location
Nashville, TN
Got rejected just because my sign is Taurus.

Apparently, being stubborn, liking my comfort, and taking my sweet time making decisions was enough to disqualify me.

Honestly, I can’t even be too mad about it. If someone is going to judge me based on my zodiac sign before actually getting to know me, maybe I saved myself some trouble anyway.

Anyone else ever been judged or rejected because of their sign?
 

Hal9000

Master Don Juan
Joined
Jun 2, 2019
Messages
874
Reaction score
1,274
If a woman places any value whatsoever in astrology you should head in the opposite direction. When dating I was amazed how many profiles excluded certain people based on their zodiac sign and, even after meeting, a surprising number of women would look me dead in the eyes and talk about their (or my) sign as if it were an actual scientific thing that has real predictive value, which it does not.

So avoid weird ass women who think they can predict the future based on someone's birthday because thats bat shart crazy and you're better off not entangling yourself with them.
 

The Duke

Master Don Juan
Joined
Feb 4, 2008
Messages
6,492
Reaction score
11,334
Yes I have been judged, never rejected. I used zodiac signs as a discussion topic for online dating. It was a good spring board for getting to know each other. A lot of women like talking about it.

There are a few girls that would probably reject you based on a bad past experience with a certain zodiac sign, however most will reject you based on their interest level not being there. It's the safer excuse to use.
 

Barrister

Master Don Juan
Joined
Apr 28, 2018
Messages
2,855
Reaction score
5,073
Age
40
Have dated a couple of chicks who placed some value on zodiac signs. Needless to say they were an extra level of crazy.

That said, it is probably a safer bet that the zodiac sign was a super convenient way of telling you just wasn't interested in you in general. When you cold approach you need a thick skin. Women come up with all sorts of excuses or tricks to avoid having to actually downright say "I am not interested in you." They tend to not be confrontational and attempt to make soft rejections. This is a perfect example.
 

CornbreadFed

Master Don Juan
Joined
Apr 7, 2023
Messages
4,628
Reaction score
3,691
Age
32
Location
Nashville, TN
Piggybacking off of @The Duke . Op, I’m not a zodiac expert but I know enough to continue a conversation with a woman. This is like sports to them to the point I haven’t met a single woman that didn’t have an interest point in zodiac. For the future, it doesn’t hurt to actually learn it instead of dismissing it as filth because it’s one of the biggest ice breakers with women. Also, I’m an Aries so literally most women are disgusted by my sign but I’m still able to fvck them hehe
 

oOh Nasty

Master Don Juan
Joined
Apr 23, 2002
Messages
1,126
Reaction score
350
Age
40
You dodged a bullet. But let me pick apart your mindset based on your original post alone.

You can be exactly what she thinks she doesn't want, but if you push her buttons correctly, you can bring that ***** home. Rejected because of [insert anything] just means you weren't attractive enough to her and/or not in the right frame. Also, trying to get a girl to get to know you is usually a bad strategy. The moment you try to open up, you will make her ***** dry. You can't take a woman to bed by reasoning with her or by trying to make her see things logically.
 

Dash Riprock

Master Don Juan
Joined
Sep 16, 2005
Messages
1,845
Reaction score
3,687
Location
Mile High City, USA
OP, you had an awesome opportunity to playfully strike back with some positive Taurus qualities and negative crap about whatever her sign is. At that point, who cares.

Knowing women love astrology, with some of the younger ones I've dated, I've used astrology as a way to game them a bit:

ME: So what's your sign?
HER: Virgo
ME: (big sigh and shake my head) Damn, and I thought this was kind of going well too.
HER: What do you mean?
ME: Well, Virgos are known to be (fill in with some funny s*it) and most criminals are Virgos too.
HER: I'm not like that!
ME: Let's hope not. Now you know why I have Dobermans at home. Look at the women I date...
HER: Well what's your sign then?
ME: I'm a Leo. It's the best sign, really, because we're ruled by the sun. So basically, everything revolves around us, as it should (sly grin). Alight Virgo girl, let's hit another spot before the cops get here. Someone probably tipped them off.

Don't be a boring stooge and play with them on it. I've actually had fun with this.
 

BillyPilgrim

Master Don Juan
Joined
Apr 9, 2021
Messages
6,042
Reaction score
4,842
Piggybacking off of @The Duke . Op, I’m not a zodiac expert but I know enough to continue a conversation with a woman. This is like sports to them to the point I haven’t met a single woman that didn’t have an interest point in zodiac. For the future, it doesn’t hurt to actually learn it instead of dismissing it as filth because it’s one of the biggest ice breakers with women. Also, I’m an Aries so literally most women are disgusted by my sign but I’m still able to fvck them hehe
Aries are reputed to have BDE. If nothing else, it's a good talking point lmao
 

Bigpapa

Master Don Juan
Joined
Nov 17, 2020
Messages
3,424
Reaction score
2,634
Got rejected just because my sign is Taurus.

Apparently, being stubborn, liking my comfort, and taking my sweet time making decisions was enough to disqualify me.

Honestly, I can’t even be too mad about it. If someone is going to judge me based on my zodiac sign before actually getting to know me, maybe I saved myself some trouble anyway.

Anyone else ever been judged or rejected because of their sign?
She was just looking for excuses to disqualify you

a lot of women act like this these days, especially on dating apps and this usually has nothing to do with you but with them as they do not have any capacity for anything ( not even casual sex )

usually they are either deep avoidants, either she was dumped and still very emotional

usually women when are very reactive because they got dumped or similar, become quite Melisandre

I encountered at some point a girl, and she was with astrology and stuff like that. After a bit of back and forth she said that all zodiacal signs of men are sh1t
 

Sega Genesis

Master Don Juan
Joined
Sep 9, 2024
Messages
968
Reaction score
720
ME: So what's your sign?
HER: Virgo
ME: (big sigh and shake my head) Damn, and I thought this was kind of going well too.
HER: What do you mean?
ME: Well, Virgos are known to be (fill in with some funny s*it) and most criminals are Virgos too.
HER: I'm not like that!
ME: Let's hope not. Now you know why I have Dobermans at home. Look at the women I date...
HER: Well what's your sign then?
ME: I'm a Leo. It's the best sign, really, because we're ruled by the sun. So basically, everything revolves around us, as it should (sly grin). Alight Virgo girl, let's hit another spot before the cops get here. Someone probably tipped them off.

Don't be a boring stooge and play with them on it. I've actually had fun with this.
Lol this is hilarious! :rofl: You should post this on any of the numerous cold approach threads running.

Especially what's in bold about Leos. As a woman, you would have had me laughing but I have a kinda warped sense of humor but I like this sort of c0cky funny approach.
 

BackInTheGame78

Moderator
Joined
Sep 10, 2014
Messages
16,818
Reaction score
19,015
Who cares why they rejected you? Also, why would you believe the reason they tell you is the actual reason? Those often times are very different.
 
Top