This reminds me of when an NBA basketball coach had stated that his team was so good, he was having a difficult time rationing out playing-minutes to the players.
He also stated that, despite this issue, it is a good problem to have as a coach because it is testament to how great the team is, and now good the players are.
So, the fact that you have a nice rotation is indeed a good thing..although it can be overwhelming to keep them all content.
I'm also going through a similar situation, so I can relate.
And as much as I love the company of women, I also value my "me"/"alone" time.
Sometimes, I just want to be at the crib, alone, unbothered..peace, and tranquility.
Instead, I gotta deal with responding to phones calls, texts...requests to come over or workout together...when sometimes, I JUST WANNA BE LEFT ALONE!!
I get a text from a chick asking me to come over...and I gotta find a way to tell her "Nah, I'm in for the night"....and I can't tell her I'll see her tomorrow, because I got plans with another one tomorrow.
It can be overwhelming...but nevertheless, are still good "problems" to have.
The solution is...
1. Keep the rotations to a tolerable minimum (whatever the # is that'll keep you from being overwhelmed).
Or..
2. Set some "I'll reach out to you if I need you, until then, don't bother me" boundaries.
My issue is; old puzzy gets old, and my constant quests for new puzzy is nonstop, unavoidable...so #2 seems to be the best option for myself.
I'm glutton for punishment, but it's still fun.