My girlfriend and I have been together for about a year. She lives with me in my apartment. I'm trying to get some honest outside opinions on whether what I'm observing are genuinely concerning patterns or whether I'm overreacting.
1. Conflict derailment During arguments, she tends to shift focus constantly — jumping between multiple points at once, which makes it impossible to resolve anything. Every conversation ends up all over the place with nothing actually addressed.
Let her roll. She may just want to vent and her frustrations or emotions may have nothing to do with you at all! She could be miffed that she's bleeding in places we don't have or she could also be miffed that the sun came up yesterday. No telling. Never react to her emotions or verbal statements directly when spoken in a less than favorable way.
When she gets angry, she raises her voice and starts shouting. This happens regularly during conflicts.
Judo principle. If she gets worse or doesn't calm down, I'd seriously reconsider her as your choice in long term companionship. How long has this been going on? Do you suspect she is wanting to have YOU tell her to leave?
3. Using shared vulnerability against me
I opened up to her about the abuse I experienced from my father growing up — decades of abuse — and how important it was for me to finally get out of that situation. I also shared that I carry a deep hatred toward him for what he did, and that parts of me wish he were dead (I made it very clear this wasn't something I planned to act on — it was emotional processing of trauma).
In a couples activity about fears and insecurities, she brought up exactly this material to say that she fears I might become physically aggressive toward her — directly linking it to what I shared about my father.
"In a couples activity?" !? Am I to understand there is counseling? Sorry mate, but I'm thinking you can see the forest for the trees with the likes of us. This is indicator #2 that she's not good for you.
4. Acknowledge and redirect
When confronted about something she did wrong, she takes a long time to acknowledge it. And when she finally does, it almost always seems to come with something that destabilizes me and shifts the blame back onto me.
Textbook narcissism (IK IK, I don't throw that word around carelessly though. It IS warranted here.) and it is a clear disregard for boundaries. In baseball, you're surely familiar with the three strikes rule?
The most recent fight was connected to that couples activity. She explained that her fear of physical aggression comes partly from her own background — she witnessed her father being physically violent toward her mother. I understand that context and take it seriously.
However, what troubled me was how she chose to express that fear: by directly linking it to the trauma I had shared with her in confidence — specifically my hatred toward my father for abusing me, and the fact that parts of me wish he were dead (something I was very clear was emotional processing, not intent).
She also wrote some times in the beginning of the relationship during arguments where she would try to walk away or leave the house, I grabbed her arm a couple of times trying to pull her back into the conversation. I recognized that was wrong, addressed it, and it hasn't happened since. I'm being transparent about this because I want the full picture out there.
"grabbed her arm" YIKES! This has got to end, man. Yesterday! I'm not an abusive man; FAR FROM IT. But I have been in relationships with women who WERE abvsed by their lovers, partners, husbands, W/E and they seemed to trigger every negative emotion in me. They would whine or complain in ways that rattle your skull like a toddler does, only it's worse, because you KNOW they're adults! I've almost crossed the threshold of grabbing, but the worst I ever did was kick a door off it's hinges (in my own house) then yell in her face like a drill instructor "AM I HITTING YOU?!?! AM I HITTING YOU?!?! ANSWER ME!!!!!!" after she said "You're JUST - LIKE - *INSERT HER EXES NAME*!!!" She was paralyzed with fear and I was also scared of myself that I'd let myself become so angry. The former Marine Sgt must have come out fully, because the neighbors heard me bark and I saw flashing lights outside. Nothing came of it though. I'm incredibly lucky.
GET OUT OF THAT situation! You don't want a bad apple to spoil your good fruits! She always claimed how easy to anger I was. As did the lady I dated after divorcing her. Lucky I only had two back to back instead of it becoming a REAL problem, but I also almost wound up calling the cops on her too! She actually physically assaulted me. No good will come of a manipulator like that.
This is a legal problem waiting to happen. You don't want arrested, mate. Take care of yourself first. I don't care how. Find a way. Stay at a friends, with parents, hotel if you can afford it, or get several of your mates over and have them help you put her stuff outside and change the locks. Also have them record everything and be ready to call the cops fast.
Are these patterns serious enough to warrant ending things, or am I letting my trauma history color how I'm interpreting her behavior?
YES! YES! and YES! They're BEYOND serious enough to end things, you're not letting your trauma history determine this, she's trying to become a prophet with things you've expressed not wanting to do. You've only grown up seeing them happen and you appear to know that they're wrong! You're second guessing your character, morality, and decency as a human being! And she's at fault for that IMHO. Yes, you are enabling her to do it though! So get out! You have a choice!
therationalmale.com
