I was a C grade level supply chain major, so I had the forced opportunities in working in some of the most undesirable & shvtty locations in the country. Small towns are only for quick sexual encounters, not for living in.
1). Most of the good women either leave or are married by the age of 21. As a result, your prime opportunities will be from women there temporary for work or for education if there's a local university. A single woman worth anything is going to gtfo as soon as the opportunity presents itself.
I don't disagree that most small towns aren't great for living in I give you that, however I've been to some towns where it makes sense for someone to work remotley and their money goes further due to cost of living. In the city for example you pay $1400 for a 1 bedroom but 3 hours in a small town $1400 will get you a 3 bedroom house and a basement. A girl I dated was paying $600 a month for a 3 bedroom house with a backyard and it was a nice house nothing gutter.
I've been to various small towns in the midwest i.e. Iowa, Wisconsin, Minnesota, South Dakota, Michigan, mostly. I've also been to various small towns in the south that I do not care for. IMO, Midwest small towns are the best. The best places to game are near a big college or college towns. As you mentioned, it's temporary, but depending on the situation, it's not always the case. A girl I was "Dating" in 2022 would drive 1.5 hour one way to see me, but in 6 months, I only went out to see her once.
2). The conservative small-town woman is a myth- They are either washed-up single moms with multiple kids out of wedlock, or they are hyper-liberalized because they are mad, they aren't living in a blue mecca state.
A bit hyperbolic but this can be true for big towns/cities as well. I would rather date a liberal small-town chick than one from a big town. I find the ones in larger cities tend to be disingenuous, trying to virtue signal. Nothing is more cringe than a woman trying to connect through talking about racism and has no clue WTF she is talking about. The amount of liberal girls who live in big cities that I met crying about the plight of women, yikes, it's easier now though to spot them now and I RUN far far away it's not even worth the cracking the cheeks as they tend to be batshyt loony tunes.
IME women who tend to be from smaller towns are more open to having traditional gender role relationships. If I'm just passing through (i.e. vacation, road trip, business) a woman's politics don't matter anyway. Long term a different story but once again, you will run into this in a big town as well.
3). You will have to break into High School Social Circles or work circles. Most people aren't going to be open to welcoming strangers into their social circles, so you will have to connect through work basically. Like I mentioned before, the people worth a shvt are trying to GTFO, so they will always be gone on the weekends doing whatever.
Nonsense I have found small town folk are more friendlier than big town folk. I have gone to Calumet, Michigan, for example, numerous times. The only minority in a biker bar(I'm talking biker gangs), people buying me shots etc. It's about how you carry yourself, like anything. I'm not trying to make friends at my age I'm trying to see what's good with the blond near the bar with big tits, small waist and a nice doneky. YEEHAW jimmy!
4). Your woman's past will not be a secret because it's a small town. More than likely, the popular Chad, Bubba, and Jah-Marien have been balls deep inside your woman and the whole town knows about it.
In a big town your woman's past isn't a secret as well if you know how to get the information or talk to the right people.
A hoe is a hoe no matter where she go. As long as she has no STD's, not trauma dumping, and keeps me satisfied, I could care less. We all got a past I'll be the first to admit it No kanye.
5). low supply- This one is obvious, but the supply of decent women is low in these towns. You will find fvcking a woman with 3 mixed kids and 1 white kid out of wedlock a relief because she is skinny and doesn't have 60% of her body tatted up.
I don't disagree with this but once again you're talking about dumpster diving. Go to a college town like Madison or Eau Claire, Wisconsin and you will find decent quality. IMO Madison is one slept on town we use to call it
"the land of 7s" cause you won't see anything above a 7 but lot of decent girls that are not just good for fun but make good girlfriends as well.
Overall you're not wrong but this can all apply for big city girls as well, however, in my experience small town girls put in more EFFORT. This is iMO where they tend to have the edge for me compared to the average city girls most members cry about being to picky entitled, narcissistic etc. Most small town girls don't give a fucc about your Instagram followers or if you're going to Mexico for spring break.
In regards to effort. I'm talking cooking, cleaning, keeping my ball sack EMPTIED whenever I wanted etc. Nothing worse to me than a pretty girl who can't cook or doesn't like too, major turn off