Kwello said:
The cold, hard, truth is more that desirable physical traits are programmed into our genetics. No matter how hard you try to convince yourself that your body shape doesn't matter, our DNA says otherwise... 5 million years of evolution doesn't change over the course of a couple thousand years (read: dawn of civilization and shifting of priorities). In modern society it would, I suppose, make more sense for a person who is either fat or has very little muscle mass to get the women (because they can either afford lots of food and are thus successful, or because they work hard to make lots of money and have no time to go to the gym).
Maybe someday that will be the case after a few million more years of evolution under the influence of society... but for now, it's pretty much hard coded into a woman's brain to find an athletic, muscular, tall man to breed with.
In fact it even corresponds with the menstrual cycle. During ovulation phases, a woman seeks a man with all of these physical traits to bear a child with. Yet during other phases, she'll seek a sensitive man who would be better suited to actually help raise the child with her.
Alpha = Child maker, holds all of the desired primal traits
Beta = Child rearer, not physically as attractive as an alpha... but a good companion
So, why not pump some iron and look like an alpha? Appeal to her primal desires. Then once you're in a committed relationship with the woman, you get to show her your caring, sensitive beta side.
Be the best of both worlds. Why settle for anything less?
Hey Kwello,
Good to hear from you. I usually prefer posts of personal experience, and I avoid abstraction in my life. That's ok, though, I appreciated your post.
All I can say is, perhaps you're right when you say it is a "cold, hard fact" that we are biologically and genetically driven to mate with muscle-headed guys. Perhaps you're wrong. Perhaps it helps, perhaps it doesn't. I really truly don't know, and couldn't possibly claim to know.
All I know is I've seen some gorgeous, drop-dead women marry some really un-gorgeous guys whose looks will drop you dead for different reasons. I know that doesn't "prove" anything, but perhaps I have seen enough of this phenomenon that I don't really worry about looks that much anymore.
So I have seen a lot of instances where women appear hard-wired to ignore physical traits and focus on personality ones. Again, I don't know, it's just that my experience doesn't mesh with what you're saying all the time.
I believe that most guys don't have enough interpersonal skills to overcome bad to decent looks. In fact, some of my friends, who were in perfect condition, were single for long stretches, while me and my out of shape buddy had hot LTRs lol.
I like what you're saying about "the best of both worlds." Not so much in terms of "alpha and beta" (which I see as metaphors of limited utility, but that's ok, if they work for you then use them), but in terms of always seeking to improve my looks and my personality. I definitely see what you're saying and respect the idea. It sounds like it's working for you and you enjoy it so I say go for it. Keep doing what makes you happy.
In my life, I guess I just find picking up women too easy. I don't feel challenged. So I'm looking for ways to make getting women more difficult, and ultimately more rewarding. I guess that's sort of at odds with the goal of this site, which is to make getting women easier. But also, please don't forget that I like compliments to my personality, and I'm not a huge fan of compliments to my body. They mean nothing to me. So my body is beautiful, so it's not. So what? It's largely genetics anyway. I could have been born deformed, and no one would think I was beautiful physically.
Do you think I would have to give up getting great women, or beautiful women? Hell no. If you would give up, feel free and I wouldn't judge worse you for it. But I don't want my game to be based on looks at all.
My favorite pickups are when I look disgusting. Like yesterday I had just biked for three hours, I was covered in sweat, my breath reeked, and my hair was a poofy mess. I then went and picked up a masseuse

For me, I felt that was a huge compliment to my personality. It couldn't have been my breath or my hair that attracted her. Quite the contrary, they probably repelled her. But we talked, I asked her on an insta-date, I got her phone number, and some touching of the hands and neck. She knows the deal.

I sorta wish I'd kissed her though. Anyway, I'm not bragging because there's really nothing extraordinary about that at all. I believe we are all capable of doing the exact same thing.
I really liked that pick up though. I must have a strong personality.
I don't really understand why you see beauty as a fixed, objective characteristic. I don't think women are hard-wired to like "tall, athletic, muscular men" I think all people are hard-wired to like beautiful, sexual people.
These are just my beliefs, you don't have to share them.
According to every philosopher since Aristotle, beauty is a subjective characteristic, ie it is in the eye of the beholder. Women aren't attracted to muscles, women are attracted to whatever society says is beautiful. But since what is beautiful is changeable, I can change what other people think is beautiful, and other people can change what I think is beautiful. What a gift.
I think what I like the most about picking up women while sorely out of shape is watching her become attracted to my body. I love that sh!t man. At first she's like wtf, this guy is odd, but I just keep at it and I just talk about who I am and what I want from life, my struggles. I talk about sex, and food, and massages. I get her to touch me and compliment me. I just love that moment where she's like "wtf? I want to sleep with this man... what is going on?"
I love that moment. What a compliment.
Izza