Do you like whole milk? I love it. Drink it everyday.Some people respond to low carb diets with higher cholesterol. Don't ask why... it just does. My HDL is 68 (heart disease-protective range), but the Paleo kept my LDL in the high range also. Triglycerides and Blood Pressure were also perfect. Dr and I did a dietician, told me to test out putting back some carbs in place of meat - LDL dropped by 46 points in 1 month, HDL and tris stayed identical.
I'm not saying the Paleo doesn't work... just work with your Dr. to gauge what your body likes and dislikes.