Not necessarily. "Old-fashioned" is also a term used to describe something that evokes nostalgia, and is often a euphemism its user employs to describe something that is proper or is done properly.Old Fashioned things done the correct way aren't technically old fashioned. Old Fashioned comes with an insinuation that it is being done inefficiently... Yet it is very difficult to speak on inefficiencies in the interpersonal realm, being that you could be dealing with an Incel or Chad.
It's also a borderline cliche for a good-looking guy to be also be an incel because he has zero game.