Derek, thanks for the props.
I don't know what the big deal is, all I was trying to say was yeah, don't worry about it, that hurts but I'll get over it like a normal person. Maybe I should have worded it differently, but I don't know why you'd say it makes me look retarded.
LOL!! All you were "trying to say was don't worry about it, that hurts but I'll get over it..." BUT YOU DIDN'T SAY THAT!! You changed the whole way she took that email with your last line about "not being head over heels either." Which was CLEARLY a last ditch effort by you to save face, that's what I was referring to when I said "it made you look like a retard." You are seeing it right when you say you should have worded it differently, but it would have been even better if you didn't reply. There was no need to say anything to her once she told you she wasn't interested.
I don't really care whether she calls me or not, all I was trying to do was smooth things over for the future with her and any other friends of ours. And as for your "of course" assesment, I don't know why you'd think "of course" anything, but I guess you're a "pimp." We went out twice after break and she seemed the same to me up until this email.
You don't care if she calls or not but you want to smooth things over with her and your other friends...If she was truely part of your group of friends and you weren't butt-hurt over this whole deal like you were trying to lead her to believe, you wouldn't have said anything. You even pointed out in your initial post that you "negged her." Your starting to contradict yourself. Oh and throwing jabs at my username fits right in with your whining about this girl
Now, after finishing my homework at 3AM, I realized I am still thinking about this and posting about this, and I realized that means I'm thinking about it way too much. Especially because, though I didn't think of this before, her email cannot be read as anything more than "i'm not interested for unspecified reason(s)." If you think about it, when you get sick of a girl, or when you meet another girl, or when you decide you're gonna join the seminary, whatever the reason, that has no bearing on how you dismiss the girl. You get rid of her in the easiest way possible, in the way that will make her feel the least bad and cause you the least trouble.
I see where your going with this but your ASSUMING that everyone handles things like you. Clearly that's not the case. Girls often feel bad giving guys the boot so they say superficial things like "I still want to be friends" or "I'll call you and we can hangout" etc etc. If everyone handled things in the easiest way possible there wouldn't be half the drama that there is between guys and girls.
So really anything could have happened here, regardless of what she says, and so perhaps all of this analysis is silly. Or perhaps not, who the heck knows.
Exactly your completely right here! Who knows what the real reason was behind her LJBF'd you. She could've been someone who was just hanging out with you because she had nothing better to do, she could have geninuely liked you at one point or she could have been utterly confused. However that's not your job to dissect or figure out. You have the only important news you need to know: She's not interested so move on.