I think there is a difference between having value, offering value, and taking value. The OP's mindset is "I have value and therefore these women should validate me." This is a "taking value" vibe that turns women off.
When you have authentic value, you become selfless. Why do you need validation? You validate others instead. You make THEM feel good. In a sense, you become the source of validation. This is the most attractive guy. He has so much, he gives it away.
A high value guy who acts like he needs validation from others offsets his own value. By taking value from people, you are expressing that you have none.
On the other hand, a LOW VALUE guy with tight game can act "value offering" and paint himself as high value.
Value - and how it is manipulated and transferred is the reason why there are so many anomalies in the game. Women can sense it. And they gravitate towards it. Being the physical embodiment of value (being good looking) is enough in most cases. But a good looking guy can act like a value taker and ruin his own value.
Nobody wants to validate the good looking guy. Everyone assumes he doesn't need it. People want validation FROM HIM.
So as a good looking dude, the proper mindset to have is "I am a value offerer. Take it or leave it. I have plenty of it."
But what a lot of good looking guys with bad game do is they go out with the mindset of "I am a good looking guy. Now give me value so that I feel validated in my belief that I am a good looking guy." It's too much "me me me." If you were truly that high value, you wouldn't need so much just to maintain your ego.
Coming from an abundance mentality, you don't need anything, but you have a lot to offer.
Now of course, it is also possible to be good looking and live in a vacuum where you have no access to women, no social life, and no abundance. These guys would have a hard time having an abundance mentality no matter how good looking they are.
People always tell you to work on your wealth and physical fitness. But they don't tell you that you also need a social life where you have a lot of access to women on a consistent basis. Without this, you will act WEIRD and miscalibrated. Your vibe will be off and women will sense it.
It's like being an Alien from a different planet coming down to earth and trying to figure out what women are attracted to. Sosuave is just a guide manual for space aliens. You need to actually live amongst women to internalize what works and what doesn't.
So many of these posts are written by dudes with absolutely zero social life that includes attractive women. They read sh1t like "Be tall and fit" and think to themselves "Okay I think I've got it. And if I still can't get laid as a tall and fit guy, there must be something wrong with women!"
No. It's not that deep. You need to surround yourself with women. There's no way around it. And once you are around enough women and start to feel them out, you will realize how desperate, needy, weird, and miscalibrated you've been this entire time.
The reason why so many posters sound like incels is because having a social life isn't preached enough. Their only interactions with women are through dating channels and there is a lack of organic interactions on a daily basis.