Thanks guys, these are the kinds of comments I was looking for. I don't usually ask for advice because I form most of my opinions from experiance, but input from other guys with experiance really helps put things in perspective.
My method involves reading the girl first. The ****ier/hotter/more confident is her the more of a 'jerk' i will be. However once I have made it clear her looks don't mean anything to me I will reward her for any information about herself and her personality. Once she opens up I turn nice, but still fun. This doesn't work on insecure girls I think, not counting girls whoa re ******dly ****y but secretly insecure.
I recenty read How To Be The Jerk Women Love and it put a lot of stuff into words for me which really helped. I've been through all this kind of stuff before but this gave me new perspective. FJ Shark says to treat the dicounts (girls lacking confidence) like premiums (girls that are hot and know it) and the premiums like discounts. Like you are saying Guybrush. I completely agree with you that David D overdoes c/f, you don't need it and in some cases it doesn't work. But that's his trademark and it's naturally the kind of guy he is.
And cheers for that post WC2, I really needed that, great advice. I have a habit of overdoing it, because was a nice guy before and when you try something else you can have a tendancy to go too far the other way. I'm way too worried about being a 'nice guy' and falling into the friends zone because of my sosuave education and nice guy history.
Imagine you were intimately talking about yourself and all she did was poke fun at you. You wouldn't be so persuaded to open up to her again would you?
I see that now. That's the difference between being a 'jerk' in the DJ sense and just a plain d!ck!