samspade said:
We've got a good debate going, here, and it's a fundamental question that is often at the base of all of the "interest level" related threads.
I suppose it boils down to whether we can be held responsible for the reactions of our reptilian minds. To what extent are we expected to temper our programmed impulses with our sense of right and wrong? If the woman in question had acted completely stoic, or even cold, toward Str8Up, she still might have found him attractive and interesting under the surface. Is she to be blamed for what she can't control?
She can be blamed for what she CAN control, but that's not so black and white. On a scale of 1 to 10, 1 being complete indifference and ten being her begging you to fukk her, where is the line of what's appropriate crossed? Is it subjective, different for each person?
I respect the opinions jophil and Str8up, so I'm interested in their (and everyone's) feedback. I don't think you can expect someone to completely suppress his or her attraction; however, if she acts out of line, I don't think she gets a free pass because of evolution, either.
This is exactly why I brought this up in the first place. You can say that a woman can't control how she feels and thus really didn't do anything wrong here. I mean, the guy in question isn't the epitome of "alpha" by any stretch of the word. Are women supposed to force themselves to not be attracted to a male that is higher up on the food chain when they are in a relationship?
I don't think anyone believes that a woman can choose who she is attracted to or when she is attracted to someone, but at the same time she CAN temper her desires. The question is, when is the line crossed?
Lets say you are dating a chick just to pass the time. Maybe you have other plates, and this one is low on the totem pole for whatever reason. A friend of hers comes into town to visit and the three of you go out for the night. Turns out her friend is drop dead gorgeous (high value for a woman), smart, witty, charming, basically everything you could ever want in a woman.
She starts to talk about subjects that you share a common interest in, and before you know it, you are engrossed in conversation with a chick you would love to get to know better. Just so happens that your low grade plate is tagging along.
Conversation in and of itself is innocent and socially expected. You can't just ignore her. So you find yourself getting along REALLY well. You have incredible rapport. You just "click".
You start asking more questions about her because you are genuinely interested in her as a person. As you become more and more attracted to her, your body language begins to shift toward her subconsciously. You can't help it....it just happens. This chick makes your plate kind of fade into the background.
Now, of course the POLITE thing to do would be to remain cognizant of your behavior and make sure you aren't excluding the plate. But that feels forced and unnatural. All you want to do is soak in this wonderful specimen of femininity.
Does this make you a "low quality" guy?
Society tries to impose a lot of rules on us, but when it comes down to it, nature trumps all. If a woman (or a man for that matter, but especially a woman) feels strong attraction to a member of the opposite sex, it's going to be difficult to suppress and hide it.
It "just happens".