So I take the idea of not giving a girl my number a bit too straightfoward!

[Vice]

So today I got a number, and when she gave me it she asked me to call her so she could have mine...

So what do I do? I say something along the lines of "Nah, I'll call you when I want.".

I don't remember where I got this idea, but I don't really like it, especially if I punched in her number wrong... plus it makes me come off as an *******. Which I already kind of are.

So should I continue this policy or should I stop?

Or am I over analyzing

 

[faiNt`]

I think you took it too literally. I'm pretty sure it means don't take her counter offer where you say "give me your number" and she asks for yours instead. If you have hers, and she wants yours, why not go ahead?

 

[Vice]

Lesson learned.