She's honest with you in her last post. That's a kiss of death.
Look guy, you validated the girl way over the top. You took time to look not just at her front pic, but through all her pics, and then you took time to write something smart ass about it, and at that you made her feel uncomfortable. Stick to classic opening lines, 'what's up. nice photos' will always get you a reply if she sees you as someone she might date. You don't have to go head over heels to get her attention.
Don't be doing sh1t like looking through her profile and finding something to comment on a particular thing. Don't be thinking that is unusual and makes you one of a kind, it is not, many many many beta man do that.
Look, if you are going to be doing that, then in return you deserve some good positive attention from her. If you want me to review your OLD profile and pics send me a link in PM.