squirrels said:
A drug dealer does not put a gun to anyone's head and make him buy his product, either. My point is that almost all the people who buy this stuff go through it, get a brief "fix" of inspiration, then fall back down into their rut. You have to have heard the phrase, "self-help junkie".
I can only speak for myself and in terms of PUA lit, I only bought DYD and Neil Strauss' The Game (which is more novel than self-help book). Not saying that junkies don't exist, but to follow that metaphor not everyone who uses drugs is a hopeless addict. Some folks are capable of moderation and plain common sense.
By your logic, nothing in the world that is remotely addictive should ever be produced, which is as absurd as me saying that motor cycle companies should go out of business because people can become addicted to adrenaline rushes and its dangerous.
Don't confuse the fact that people were willing to PAY for his material with the idea that his material is worth what it's being represented as worth.
Who is really qualified to decide what something is worth to someone else? You are working off the assumption that most people are willing to wade through forums to find this info. Not everyone has such inclination and would rather have answers delivered to them for a fee rather than dig for them. It's a perfectly reasonable demand.
At the end of the day who is really better off.. the "sucker" who buys an e-book, learns enough from it to improve his game and move on - or the "enlightened" fellow who got all that info for free on a forum to which he has devoted thousands of posts, hours and energy? Ultimately nothing is really for free. Time is money too (actually its more valuable by far)
By that definition, Bernie Madoff is an honest businessman as well.
Madoff robbed people blind and was rightfully convicted of fraud. There is a BIG difference!
I mean, yeah, I guess I have to give him credit for finding enough people stupid enough to pay him money for this information instead of getting out there and acquiring it for themselves, but what bothers me is how these "gurus" pretend to OWN this information and proceed to PROFIT off of it, when really it's free-to-all. What gives him the right to slap his name on it and charge $50 or $100 or $1000? It's like those people who wanted to copyright the color blue or something.
Yes, the game has been hashed and rehashed a million times, there is nothing new under the sun, etc etc. But it's not like the guy just copied and pasted sosuave articles. He took a few of the basic principles and weaved them together in an easy-to-read format which made sense for a lot of people. THAT is where the value is.
Don't be mad because some dudes are actually making a decent living with their writing when the only demonstration of your talent can be found in the sad, depressing little posts you write. The fact of the matter is that Eben wrote that ebook in a matter of weeks and created a fortune for himself out of thin air. You've written thousands of free posts for YEARS and have nothing to show for it - not even the happiness or fulfillment that comes from helping others.
The term "sore loser" comes to mind here.