What the OP is doing / looking for is pretty normal... the only problem is, he's doing it with the wrong women. Like someone else said, you gotta weed 'em out until you find a decent one. Do NOT view everyone as relationship material. If they're all about the bad boy player ONS FWB - they're not going to be keepers. You gotta categorize people accordingly. It's also very true that you attract what you project.
Of course, it's not as easy it sounds. Familiarity is tough to break. And attraction is ****. But you gotta look at what you want, and the results you're getting. You can't have it all, unfortunately.
This applies to friendships, as well. All of those players, street losers, party goers, etc make horrible friends. They're "cool", out-going, and fun to hang with, but they're also fake, selfish, manipulative, two-faced, etc. It's all the same.