Dominus
Master Don Juan
Hey guys! Anyone remember me? Been a long time since I contributed anything here. I've spent most of my online time at an alternate history forum (where we discuss the 'what ifs" of history, yeah, we're nerds). Anyway, one of the younger kids on the forum started a thread asking for relationship advice, and I did my best to help. Eventually, the admin of the board weighed in on the thread and gave his advice. It was such good stuff that I felt the need to come back here and repost it. There's really nothing new in it, but its well put, so here it is.
1. Confidence is key.
Women like confidence far, far more than men do. Think about it - shy "nice guys" legendarily get passed over, whereas being shy and nice is not much impediment to a girl getting asked out (in fact lots of guys really like it). If you ask 10 women for what they're looking for in a man you'll likely get ten quite different lists, but probably at least 9 in 10 of them will mention "confidence" or something equivalent.
When you want to date a woman, don't do things that would make it look like you aren't confident. I'm going to mention some below, but it's not magic, and the main secret is to build your own inner confidence. Easy to say, almost impossible to do... or is it?
2. Confidence is *not* about expecting success, or about being successful. It's about *not fearing failure*.
You can be completely confident about doing something you'll probably fail at, if you know it's not a big deal and you can move on. In high school, everything social tends to seem Incredibly Important. But it's not - unless you're a total ass, asking somebody out and getting turned down won't make you into a social failure. In fact, it's essential - dealing with rejection is a skill that takes practice. You have to go in with the attitude that even a total stud would get rejected by the majority of women if he just asks a whole bunch of them out, so you *will* get turned down. Even when there's absolutely nothing wrong with you. It's still going to sting the first few times anyway, but if you keep in mind that rejection is natural and dating is always a gamble, you can learn to deal with "no" as an oh well, that's the way it goes sometimes, everyday event. In contrast, guys who have the attitude that "no" means there's something wrong with them, that they don't understand women or women don't understand them, and so on will eventually get really bitter. Especially when it comes to the immature minds of high school girls, "no" does *not* mean there's anything wrong with you, trust me. If women never tell you no, you're probably not trying hard enough.
3. The best way to display confidence with women is not to put them up on a pedestal.
A lot of "nice guys" go to a lot of effort specifically to win a woman over, treating her much better than they'd treat anyone they were just friends with. Being extra-nice to her, trying not to offend her, trying to be the kind of person she'd like them to be, giving her flowers, paying for absolutely everything, and so on. Basically they throw all this effort at her, to "win" her, and they try to get the "reward" of her going out with them. This gives all the power to the woman - the guy makes it clear that he'll go far to get her, and all she has to do is decide whether to say yes or no.
If you think about it for a minute, you'll realize this isn't a confident thing to do. A really desirable guy doesn't have to go that far - he can be himself, he can even be a demanding jerk, if he asks women out they'll say "yes" without being showered with flowers and inoffensiveness. Now, you're not Brad Pitt, but that actually doesn't matter - the most important way to become desirable is to act as if you are already desirable. In other words, be casual. Just ask women out as if it were a completely everyday thing (even if you are really scared inside). And *don't give them things unless they're willing to give in return*. And I don't mean some disgusting bull**** like if you pay for dinner she should sleep with you. I mean, if you do something nice for a woman then you should expect her to be nice in return. If not you can move on, you can legitimately get annoyed, you can call her on it. But whatever you do, *do not* keep doing more nice things in the hope that she will go out with you or like you better. Doing that makes you look like the sort of person who isn't confident in their own attractiveness, and tries to be extra-nice and extra-giving to compensate.
"Don't go out of your way to be nice to a woman in order to win her over" is contrary to received wisdom in North American culture. Tradition and movies tell a guy how to be "romantic" and how to date, and what they say is basically to be giving and try to win her over. That's crap. With most women, it actually *decreases* your chances. Instead of starting the relationship off on an equal footing you're giving her all the power - and it's hard for a powerless guy to seem confident.
4. Ironically enough, treat them a bit more like friends and you're less likely to be "just friends".
As I said above, doing a lot of nice things for a woman without her returning the favor is the sort of thing that makes it look like you're not confident and thus not attractive. But knowing how not to drive women away is not the same as being able to attract them. The easiest way to seem confident in an *attractive* way is to treat women the way you might treat a friend of yours, especially a kind of bratty friend that you like to kid around with a lot. Geeky "nice guys" may kid around with and tease other guys a lot (just see this board and even this thread...) but they usually never do it with women, especially women they're interested in. Big mistake. Women like you to be a fun person that can kid around with them, not someone who's serious and uncomfortable. And if you can kid around with and tease or be sarcastic with a woman you're trying to date, that *really* makes you stand out from other guys in a good way, and shows that you're confident enough not to be worried about offending her.
And that really is key - *don't worry about offending her*. Within reason, of course - don't insult her or tell the most extreme gross-out jokes you know. But think of how you probably act with guy friends - if one of your jokes goes over the wrong way you just say oops, didn't mean it that way and that's it. If you talk about a controversial subject and don't agree, no big deal. But most guys worry a lot about offending women they date, and so they try and play it "safe" and uncontroversial. Instead, treat her like a normal person whose opinion isn't a matter of life and death to you. If you express an opinion she doesn't like or tease her in a way she doesn't like, generally her negative reaction will be *far* outweighed by the fact that you just showed yourself to be much more self-confident than other guys. And you've showed that since you're willing to kid around and be open about what you think, she can do the same things in return. This will create bonds of trust and lead to deeper conversations earlier in the relationship.